France’s President Emmanuel Macron provides the keynote deal with on the Shangri-La Dialogue Summit in Singapore on May 30, 2025.
Ludovic Marin | Afp | Getty Images
European leaders want to Southeast Asia with renewed pastime amid Washington’s competitive tariff schedule, however mavens warn that the state of regional business ties makes it difficult to disrupt the U.S. or China’s dangle.
Southeast Asia is in a catch 22 situation: its best friend China is ramping up its advances within the South China Sea, with state of the art Chinese bomber planes. noticed within the disputed Paracel Islands within the area past due ultimate month as tensions flare with the Philippines. Meanwhile, its different best friend, the U.S., hangs the specter of price lists over the sector, with uncertainty mounting as a 90-day reprieve is set to run out in July.
Europe is now seizing the chance to floor as a substitute best friend to rising Asian international locations, with French President Emmanuel Macron calling for more potent ties between the blocs on the 2025 Shangri-La Dialogue that wrapped up previous this month.
Southeast Asia brings Europe the chance to get right of entry to every other marketplace for its protection sector, in line with Bob Herrera-Lim, managing director at Teneo. Ifri’s Pajon provides that the area may additionally supply Europe a assorted provide chain to hedge in opposition to financial reliance at the U.S. or China and important uncooked subject matter reserves crucial for the EU’s inexperienced and virtual transition.
Europe is bold in its hopes for rising Asia, however analysts however doubt it will probably overtake the U.S. or China’s affect within the area.
“Europe, on its own, can offer Southeast Asia a valuable option to hedge against the risks of overdependence on either China or the United States,” Céline Pajon, head of Japan and Indo-Pacific Research at Ifri’s Center for Asian Studies, advised CNBC through electronic mail.
Trade trumps all
While ties span greater than part a century, Southeast Asian and European members of the family were mired in quite a lot of demanding situations that Teneo’s Herrera-Lim attributes to components equivalent to geographic distance and diverging perspectives over politics or the surroundings.
In his keynote speech on the 2025 Shangri-La Dialogue, Macron referred to as for more potent ties between Europe and the Indo-Pacific’s “new special relationship.” He wired that each blocs are dealing with the “potential erosion of long-time alliances” and the specter of international locations vying for keep watch over or resorting to power, drawing direct parallels between China’s advances within the South-China Sea and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Yet an identical studies on my own will not be sufficient to sway rising Asia clear of the U.S. or China, in line with Herrera-Lim.
“Form follows function in Southeast Asia,” he advised CNBC in a decision, “Relationships are built on economic ties in Southeast Asia, more than anything else.”
While the EU has business ties with Singapore and Vietnam, talks for different bilateral offers or an EU-ASEAN extensive loose business agreements (FTA) were stalled for years, and Ifri’s Pajon stated that the bloc “still has progress to make” in expanding its presence and funding within the area.
Meanwhile, Beijing stays the Southeast Asia’s greatest buying and selling spouse since 2009, with general items in business achieving $982.3 billion in 2024. The U.S. follows in the back of in 2d position, with an estimated $476.8 billion items in business ultimate yr. The EU trails in the back of in 3rd position, with kind of 258.7 billion euros ($299.7 billion) of products in business over the similar duration.
Without any significant reform or the promise of higher business one day, Herrera-Lim stated that it’ll be tough for Europe to compete in opposition to the bloc’s established buying and selling companions.
“If in the next week or next month, China says, ‘We’re doing reforms so that domestic markets are opened up in China for Southeast Asian goods,’ [then] Southeast Asian countries would line up to get access to the Chinese market. Independent of their politics around many of these issues,” he stated.
Resisting
While Europe may no longer be capable to change the U.S. or China in rising Asia, it will probably however be offering clear, dependable partnerships that are not about zero-sum festival, Lizza Bomassi Research Analyst on the European Union Institute for Security Studies (EUISS), advised CNBC through electronic mail.
“Europe’s value proposition lies in being a reliable partner in critical areas like energy security, green infrastructure, and digital governance,” she stated, “These are areas where Southeast Asian countries want to diversify and build resilience, especially given concerns about overdependence.”
Ifri’s Pajon stated that strengthening ties with Europe would permit Southeast Asia to diversify its strategic partnerships and support their capability to withstand hegemonic pressures.
“The presence of more partners, including Europe, raises the diplomatic and reputational costs for China to escalate [territorial disputes in the region], particularly given Beijing’s emphasis on a ‘peaceful rise’,” Bomassi stated.
“In this context, the EU-ASEAN partnership isn’t about hard military deterrence, but it serves as a crucial symbolic defence mechanism. It reinforces that Southeast Asia isn’t isolated and has multiple partners, making the region more resilient to coercion,” she added.