A marketer walks right into a Dublin bar. No, this isn’t the beginning of a crude funny story – it’s Andrew Tindall’s dispatch from Google Marketing Live, the place the demos dazzled, the acronyms flew, and AI promised to do the give you the results you want. But if the machines are busy development campaigns, what’s left for the people?
I admit that AI terrifies me. I joined advertising and marketing simply as issues have been moving from massive, robust TV commercials with a few different bits to loss of life by means of spreadsheet. Facing your fears is just right for the soul, regardless that, so the place higher to be informed about all this than in Dublin, at Google Marketing Live 2025?
Polished cubicles, speedy demos or even sooner acronyms… I spent two days surrounded by means of entrepreneurs, product managers and PowerPoint decks, all centred on one massive concept: Google’s AI stack. After I Googled (lol) what an AI stack was once, I strapped in for the brand new frontier of selling.
There was once so much to soak up. I reckon I’m a quite tuned-in marketer, however issues are progressing at a price of knots. Smart Bidding Exploration. Generative AI that creates complete campaigns in seconds. Agentic techniques that don’t simply suggest, however act. A set of equipment designed to automate bidding, asset advent, marketing campaign structuring or even dimension (nonetheless looking ahead to one to dam chilly outreach emails regardless that). The promise? You do much less, AI does extra, and function climbs. Apparently, entrepreneurs the usage of AI see 60% extra income expansion (that’s from BCG, so it will have to be true *foolish face*).
Some of it in point of fact was once spectacular. Genuinely. Which is most definitely why I wished a pint after.
I left the development and did what any marketer would do in Dublin with a head filled with product demos and a abdominal filled with long run pondering. I went to Temple Bar. Alone. And ordered a Guinness. One became 5. Each pint introduced with it a brand new revelation.
[Editor’s note: Andrew emailed me this at 1am. Large parts of it made sense. I managed to scrape together the below.]Pint one: I don’t know whether or not to chortle or cry
Some of those equipment are correctly artful. Genuinely brain-melting in portions. Smart Bidding Exploration. Generative asset advent. Campaign automation. Makes your process more uncomplicated. Much more uncomplicated. But what’s a foolish little human marketer’s function in all this? Especially when bits of it really feel like we’re now dedicated to following other folks across the web.
Like the bit the place AI can spot intent indicators ahead of you even know you wish to have one thing. Minority Report however with banner commercials. Sold to ahead of you even realise you’re purchasing.
Just as I polished off pint one, Orlando Wood known as me. We chatted whilst I fingered a bag of beef scratchings and informed him about Google’s new AI superpowers. He known as it “salesmanship on steroids.”
I informed him he was once being too harsh, whilst choking on what I presume was once a pig’s nipple. But he had some degree. At its easiest, these items provides us house to suppose. To plan. To construct exact inventive. But at its worst…
Want to head deeper? Ask The Drum
Pint two: Smart bidding, dumb pondering
These equipment are designed to automate the doing. Which is good. Until it’s now not. If AI handles focused on, inventive and bid control, the place precisely are you including price?
The risk is entrepreneurs omit to suppose. They prevent writing right kind briefs. They let the equipment lead technique. You save time, sure. But what are you doing with it?
No set of rules will inform you what your emblem must imply. Or who you must topic to. Or what fact you’re unlocking. AI may well be finding out speedy, however it could actually’t construct your emblem’s soul. Assume the platform does the heavy lifting, and also you’ll finally end up with a marketing campaign with out a level.
Pint 3: Agentic is a foolish phrase
Let’s speak about everybody’s new favorite jargon: “agentic advertising.” Remember when it is advisable to pass weeks in advertising and marketing with out listening to “agentic”?
No one in point of fact is aware of what it manner. Google (the hunt engine, now not the convention) defines it as giving AI the facility to behave to your behalf. Helpful little bots development your media plan whilst you crack on with… neatly, no matter else it’s we do.
In principle, superb. If paired with inventive route and strategic pondering, it might loose us up to concentrate on the great things. Less time on Gantt charts. Perhaps extra time making paintings that doesn’t make other folks need to claw their eyes out. Ah, the AI dream. Time for pint 4.
Pint 4: AI is a reflect and a few entrepreneurs received’t like what they see
We’ve cracked AI for advertising and marketing potency. So now it’s exposing entrepreneurs who aren’t efficient.
If all of your shtick is tweaking CTRs and development rational campaigns… AI can do all that. Better. Faster. Cheaper. Google proved that this week.
The taking part in box is levelling. Even small manufacturers can now make big-feel inventive in weeks. (Seriously, take a look at Google’s “Veo 3”). If you have been doing moderate paintings, you’re now not even moderate to any extent further.
The simplest unfair benefits left? Proper creativity. Real technique. Emotional intelligence. The stuff that may’t be templated.
I’m scripting this within the nook of a pub, fag placing from my mouth, and it in fact looks like I’m again within the 90s doing one thing tough. My editor goes to have to clean this blank. But it wishes pronouncing.
Pint 5: A Slane chaser. And a right kind realisation.
My ultimate pint got here with a whiskey. Slane Irish triple cask, rested to perfection. (I used to paintings for them, but it surely in point of fact is just right stuff.)
As the heat unfold and I began pondering I must most definitely name my ex, I realised the largest level of the day: if AI provides entrepreneurs time again… what are we going to do with it?
I fear maximum received’t use it to construct higher concepts. They’ll in finding new spreadsheets. Tinker with dashboards. Dive into engagement information that also doesn’t hyperlink to gross sales.
We’re hooked on busyness. AI gives freedom, that is our probability.
So right here’s the problem: if AI’s going to carry our beer, we higher use each arms to do one thing significant. Write smarter briefs. Build emotional platforms. Fight tougher for inventive that entertains and builds memorability. Proper analysis and technique.
This shift isn’t coming. It’s right here. Google (and others I’ve now not troubled to learn into but) have pulled their finger out. I’ll get booed for scripting this, but it surely’s time to prevent pretending this isn’t a large shift. Adopt the tech. Double down on what people do easiest. Or get automatic out of relevance.
Kebab time. This was once weirdly enjoyable. Might be what journaling looks like. Hope my mum doesn’t learn this. She’ll know I’m a under the influence of alcohol.