Kristen Stewart’s ‘The Chronology of Water’ Stays Too Close to the Surface

For her function directorial debut, the actor Kristen Stewart has selected to conform a difficult, lyrical memoir a couple of girl looking to out-swim a anxious formative years and habit. In The Chronology of Water, the author Lidia Yuknavitch main points the sexual abuse she skilled by the hands of her father and its lengthy aftermath, from a scuttled aggressive swimming occupation to new objective discovered, years later, in writing. It’s a troublesome piece, however Stewart has proven in her appearing paintings that she’s keen on daunting duties.

The movie, which premiered right here on the Cannes Film Festival on May 16, isn’t any timid first foray into filmmaking. Stewart dives in full-body, protecting issues ever in speedy movement—flickering ahead and backward in time, ratcheting up top emotion after which unexpectedly breaking right into a second of dreamy peace. The effort is liked, despite the fact that all that taste—on the other hand true it’s to Yuknavitch’s prose—can from time to time weigh down the which means in the back of it.

Imogen Poots performs a model of Yuknavitch, from early life on. A promising freestyle swimmer with potentialities of school recruitment, teenage Lidia most likely sees athletics as her most effective get away from the regimen horrors of her house. Her sister fled years in the past, and Lidia is determined to observe swimsuit. But, in fact, bodily distance isn’t all that’s required to flee such lasting hurt. Lidia turns to medicine and alcohol to vanish, and shortly reveals herself booted out of college and stumbling off into a completely unsure long run, with intercourse and ingredients her most effective consistent.

There’s a undeniable, linear tale in there, however Stewart is extra within the jumbled interiority of the thoughts. Her movie bobs and weaves and loops, regularly developing an image of a lady each looking to rid herself of her ache and, in a sophisticated and from time to time fruitful manner, feeding off of it. The Chronology of Water is continuously a troublesome sit down, an oppressive temper piece steeped in unease and sadness. There are transcendent, beautiful interludes, however for the primary part of the movie, we really feel ourselves drowning simply as Lidia is.

Which is successfully the purpose. It’s demanding to ding Stewart for placing us in the correct mindframe. What nettles, or disappoints, about Chronology is that Stewart will pay extra time to prospers of chaos and melancholy than she does to actually sussing out the memoir’s central metaphors and conclusions. Despite tons of voiceover immediately from the e book, we don’t actually come to grasp Yuknavitch’s thesis. Maybe there isn’t one, however I longed for a more potent tether between the phrases being mentioned aloud and the photographs accompanying them. I’ve for sure that Stewart has a deep seize at the philosophy of Chronology, however she doesn’t do sufficient to give an explanation for it to us within the target audience. A too-close-to-the-case ardor for the fabric does the movie a disservice, as can from time to time occur when a liked object is customized. (“There are voices that help you find yours,” Stewart instructed VF previous this week of Yuknavitch’s paintings. “It became a sacred text for me overnight.”)

The movie exists at a take away, extra object for formal find out about than one thing deeply felt. What does emotionally resonate feels unspecific to anyone writer; it’s only a generic, if compelling, story of hard-won restoration. Stewart implies poetry reasonably than conjures it. The target audience will simply need to believe her in regards to the wonders of Yuknavitch’s explicit energy.

Some of Chronology’s busy craft is admirable, despite the fact that, as is the breakneck efficiency on the middle of the movie. While Poots from time to time hits a flat word, I believe the ones are extra the fault of an over-indicating script. In all different means, Poots fiercely commits to the lengthy adventure of cave in and catharsis. She performs under the influence of alcohol with a bracing veracity, storming thru a lot of the movie in a mad reel. She’s resonant within the movie’s softer stretches too, pain and sour disillusionment pooled in her eyes. The movie asks numerous its celebrity, requiring a definite stage of bravery and believe, and Poot’s paintings would recommend that Stewart supplied secure, comfy haven for a performer taking a look to take a large soar.

I did yearn for extra discussion—for extra time to in truth get to grasp Lidia past what’s poetically however vaguely elucidated in voiceover. Poots is greater than a trifling vessel for snippets from the e book, however she could be higher served through a script that gave her extra to play in any scene’s provide hectic. The complete impact of Stewart’s fast-cut collage is that Lidia, and Poots, appear most effective to go with the flow during the movie reasonably than are living in it. Still, cheers to Stewart for tackling one thing daring and sophisticated in her first day out, and for bringing additional consideration to an acclaimed however lesser identified memoir. Maybe learn the e book first, then watch the movie because the artiest roughly supplemental subject material.

This tale is a part of Awards Insider’s in-depth Cannes protection, together with first seems and unique interviews with one of the tournament’s largest names. Stay tuned for extra Cannes tales in addition to a distinct complete week of Little Gold Men podcast episodes, recorded are living from the competition and publishing each day.

Listen to Vanity Fair’s Little Gold Men podcast now.