BBC North East & Cumbria Investigations

In October 2024 the federal government introduced it used to be cancelling a venture to widen a part of the A1 in Northumberland, years after National Highways had spent greater than £4m at the acquire of homes and land in the best way of the scheme.
The affected households – together with one couple who needed to get started afresh miles away in Cumbria – stated they’d “been through hell” as they noticed their houses “left to rot” unnecessarily.
Melanie Wensby-Scott sat in her automotive and cried at the day she and her husband left Northgate House, which sits proper subsequent to the street no longer a long way from Morpeth.
The couple have been packing up the closing in their property and she or he used to be nonetheless operating the vacuum cleaner round when National Highways contractors arrived.
“They started boarding up the windows and changing the locks,” she stated. “I honestly felt like we were being evicted.”

Melanie and her husband Julian had had “big plans” once they purchased the home in 2009.
“We put in a new kitchen, new bathrooms, we were planning a new conservatory and we had no intention of ever leaving,” she stated.
But in 2014, the then Prime Minister David Cameron introduced plans to twin a 13-mile segment of the A1 and it turned into transparent their area used to be within the trail of the selected path.
“When they first came round I said I didn’t want to move and they basically said I had no option,” stated Mrs Wensby-Scott.
“It was just awful to know you were going to lose your home.”


The A1 scheme stalled for a couple of years, alternating between in a position to start out and nonetheless on hang till, in May 2024, Rishi Sunak’s govt authorized the Development Consent Order which gave the general go-ahead.
However, Labour swept again into energy two months later and cancelled the venture in October 2024, mentioning it needed to make “difficult decisions about road schemes which were unfunded or unaffordable”.
Mrs Wensby-Scott stated: “When I heard the news, I just thought ‘oh my God all that for nothing’.
“Everything we went thru, the heartache, the angst, I simply could not consider it.
“You drive past now and it’s falling apart, it just looks awful. It’s such a shame, it was such a beautiful house.”

At the opposite finish of the proposed path, Felicity and James Hester had been residing in East Cottage close to the village of Rock.
It used to be a “perfect place” for them as it had a paddock and stabling for his or her horses, however they quickly realised the bulldozers had been heading their manner.
“It was just horrible,” Mrs Hester stated. “We went through four or five years of utter hell trying to find somewhere we could actually move to, it was just a nightmare.
“The manner the valuables marketplace used to be on the time in Northumberland, we could not in finding the rest which matched what we had so we needed to transfer to Cumbria.
“Now we’re a couple of hours away from all the friends we had.”

Next to East Cottage is Charlton Mires, a big 200-year-old farmhouse and steadings that have been the house of the Beal circle of relatives since 1904, however would additionally want to be flattened for street construction.
Martin Beal described its loss as “very painful”.
“I felt like I’d let my family down somehow because I couldn’t save our home,” he stated. “There are just so many memories in there.
“They had been additionally taking a part of our land, so I could not plan forward. I had sleepless nights, it used to be very laborious.”

A freedom of information request by the BBC revealed that more than £68m had already been spent on the A1 scheme by the time it was cancelled, and that figure continues to rise by just under £30,000 a month.
That is partly because National Highways is obliged to pay insurance and council tax on the unneeded properties, including an empty house premium.

Land agent Louis Fell, who represented the Hester and Beal families, described the situation as “a large number”
He stated: “I do know National Highways did not make the verdict to cancel the street, however they want to have a method for the houses, most likely imagine refurbishing them and renting them to younger households.
“For them just to sit here rotting is such a waste of money and it’s not a good look for an area popular with tourists.”

National Highways prior to now stated it used to be “sympathetic” to Mr Beal’s scenario after delays to bills for his assets.
In a commentary, it stated: “We carefully review expenditure on all our projects to ensure that lessons are learned and processes are improved for any future road improvement schemes.
“Discussions surrounding the way forward for the houses bought as a part of this scheme stay ongoing and will likely be communicated sooner or later.
“The properties are being managed by our estates team until a strategy is agreed.
“During this time, the houses will likely be secured via our upkeep contractor and inspected on an acceptable foundation.”

Under what are known as the Crichel Down rules, in situations like this the properties should be offered back to the owners, but all three families say they do not wish to go back to homes which have been empty for several years.
Martin Beal said his former home was “filled with damp and falling aside”.
He now has permission to build a new farmhouse nearby but when it is built, because it is a direct replacement for Charlton Mires, planning arrangements mean the original farmhouse has to be demolished at a cost to the taxpayer of an estimated £100,000.
“It has been there for 200 years, it is a gorgeous area. It is simply ridiculous it needs to be demolished for not anything,” Mr Beal lamented.
“I’m simply so indignant about the entirety my oldsters and I’ve been thru, and all the ones tens of millions of kilos wasted for what?”