NFL Draft Live: Did we hit and miss on each and every first-round select?

The NFL Draft’s first around is within the books and Rivals recruiting director Adam Gorney shared his reminiscences of each and every select all over the primary around, and defined why they have been ranked the place they have been in highschool.

CLASS OF 2025 RANKINGS: Rivals250 | Team | Position | State

CLASS OF 2026 RANKINGS: Rivals250 | Team | Position | State

CLASS OF 2027 RANKINGS: Rivals250 | Team | Position | State

TRANSFER PORTAL: Full protection | Player rating | Team rating | Transfer seek | Transfer Tracker

Gorney’s lookback: Cam Ward is the primary No. 1 in Rivals historical past relationship again to 2002 that used to be unranked in highschool. He used to be now not heralded in highschool, went to Incarnate Word and shined sooner than moving to Washington State and dominating there and completed his profession at Miami.

It used to be now not a blank trail and he used to be now not the marquee within the 2020 elegance that used to be led at QB via Bryce Young however Ward earned the whole thing alongside the way in which. LeSean McCoy stated he wasn’t bought on Ward as a result of he wasn’t a five-star man. In a foul quarterback draft elegance, Ward is via some distance the most efficient of the bunch and earned being taken No. 1 general each step of the way in which.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Miss

Gorney’s lookback: There will probably be a dialogue about whether or not Colorado‘s Travis Hunter can play offense and protection within the NFL and whilst it is not going, the previous five-star is without doubt one of the maximum impactful avid gamers now we have observed in Rivals historical past. He has actually never-ending power, loves the sport, loves festival and he is via some distance the most efficient athlete on this draft elegance.

Watching Hunter’s tape is like observing Charles Woodson‘s or Champ Bailey‘s on rapid ahead. From a 7on7 match right through COVID in Bullhead City, Ariz., to a large number of camps and all-star video games thru his highschool profession, Hunter used to be all the time a human spotlight reel and he additionally had the largest signing day turn in Rivals historical past going from Florida State to Jackson State.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Hit

Gorney’s lookback: Rated as a four-star linebacker throughout the Rivals250, Abdul Carter used to be now not the quickest on this planet however he hit like a truck at Philadelphia (Pa.) La Salle. Penn State did not love him in the beginning, presented him however then had him come again for summer season camp to peer if he may just devote. It used to be a sensible determination as he picked the Nittany Lions over Ole Miss and South Carolina basically.

He transformed to an edge rusher and had an incredible 24 tackles for loss and 12 sacks this season, even with one arm now and then on account of harm. Carter’s development may be the most important word for larger linebackers in highschool – shifting right down to the threshold may well be the wisest transfer.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: Will Campbell used to be exceptional on the Rivals Camp in Dallas and we did not pull the cause on making him a five-star. The four-star offensive take on has nice athleticism and there is a country-strong mentality to his recreation. Yeah, his fingers are so much shorter than many others but it surely didn’t harm him in highschool, he ruled at LSU and he will have to’ve been a five-star popping out.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: Mason Graham used to be a beast popping out of Anaheim (Calif.) Servite as a two-way lineman as he regarded nice at each offensive and defensive position. As time went on, Graham began to emerge as an ideal inner defensive lineman who may just use his bodily nature to win on the line of scrimmage. He most effective were given higher and higher at Michigan the place he persevered to increase bodily and from a method viewpoint.

We beloved Graham so much in highschool however obviously now not sufficient as we did not ID him as a five-star prospect.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: Ashton Jeanty used to be a two-star popping out of Frisco (Texas) Lone Star which seems silly now since he post huge numbers in highschool but if he went to Boise State it used to be nonetheless a query whether or not he would play operating again, receiver or are available in as an athlete.

Jeanty used to be a Heisman Trophy finalist for the Broncos this season as he bounced off all comers this season. Penn State necessarily close him down however he had an ideal recreation towards Oregon and I simply wonder whether taking a operating again this prime is worthwhile.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Miss

Gorney’s lookback: We noticed Armand Membou in highschool and he attended Rivals Camp however his frame essential some reshaping and we were not bought that somebody simply over 6-foot-4 may just make it as an elite offensive take on on the subsequent point and past.

We have been fallacious as a result of his arm duration at 82 inches is elite, he can energy thru defensive linemen and he has exceptional steadiness. We have been fallacious on Membou, who we concept would have a pleasant school profession however would not be just about as dominant as he became out to be at Missouri.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Miss

Gorney’s lookback: There were questions on whether or not Tetairoa McMillan “loves football” and to be fair I had the similar issues the primary few instances I met him. He used to be taking part in in – let’s name it – an underground soccer 7on7 match right through COVID subsequent to a capturing vary in Corona, Calif. He used to be so quiet and reserved it used to be onerous to believe he may just flip it on. So quiet that he used to be uncomfortable doing an interview. He went to Hawaii as soon as right through the recruiting procedure and did not even take his telephone.

But between the strains he is an absolute canine. He’s ultra-competitive and he has unreal steadiness, playmaking skill and arms. Pairing him with somebody like Bryce Young will probably be a really perfect are compatible.

Over time as I were given to grasp him higher, I most effective appreciated him increasingly and he ended up as a five-star receiver. TMac used to be additionally an excessively prepared blocker in video games and I beloved to peer him flip that on as neatly.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Hit

Gorney’s lookback: Congratulations to Kelvin Banks as a result of his resume at Texas made him a first-round variety however for us within the ratings industry, this one is heartbreaking. We had Banks as a five-star previous within the cycle and he used to be out of the ordinary on the Dallas Rivals Camp. He simply bullied everyone, had an ideal, barrel-chested body and used to be simply superior. But then we noticed him fight mightily on the Under Armour Game. He used to be apparently unhealthy, and we overreacted and dropped him to a four-star.

We have been fallacious. He’s 6-foot-5, 315 kilos and has a wingspan of 84 3/8 inches. What else may just we’ve in all probability sought after? If he used to be simply OK on the Under Armour Game, he would’ve stayed a 5 and rightfully so.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: We by no means noticed Colston Loveland in highschool as he went to university in rural Idaho and not attended any giant occasions. His tape used to be remarkable, despite the fact that, and he ended up as a four-star prospect however out of doors of the Rivals250 as a result of we needed to be conservative on his rating since he used to be taking part in very low-level festival and we did not see him anyplace.

Michigan beat out Oregon State and Boise State in what ended up being a very easy name. But with Penn State‘s Tyler Warren nonetheless in the market, this does not look like the most efficient select conceivable.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: Mykel Williams remains to be 20 years outdated and if Travon Walker used to be worthy of being the No. 1 general select then San Francisco is getting a thieve right here within the first around. Williams performs onerous, has all of the very best measureables at 6-foot-5 and 267 kilos with lengthy fingers and looks as if the prototypical NFL edge rusher.

And giant credit score is going to Georgia trainer Kirby Smart as a result of till halfway thru his senior season, Williams used to be dedicated to USC. It used to be most effective as a result of Smart by no means gave up, saved going after Williams after which after all flipped him after an in-home consult with that Georgia landed him.

Williams has each metric to achieve success within the NFL and past as a former five-star.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Hit

Gorney’s lookback:We will have to’ve been upper on Tyler Booker. He measured just below 6-foot-5 and 321 kilos with extremely lengthy fingers at greater than 84 inches so that may be a studying lesson for us shifting ahead – take a shot on guys with all of the metrics.

Booker used to be now not as bodily in highschool as he used to be as soon as he were given to Alabama and truly followed a tricky, imply mentality on that offensive line. Georgia used to be believed to be the frontrunner in his recruitment with Florida, Oregon and others however the Crimson Tide received out.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: What has this draft informed elite highschool defensive tackles up to now? Want to be a primary rounder, Michigan isn’t a foul position to be. Mason Graham went previous within the first around and now Kenneth Grant is off the board.

The fear with Grant popping out of Merrillville, Ind., used to be that he used to be 340 kilos and did not essentially elevate all of it that neatly. He used to be rapid and bodily for his dimension however we obviously didn’t see a possible first-rounder there, particularly since he used to be ranked as a prime three-star.

It is a bit of sudden that Miami went with Grant since Oregon‘s Derrick Harmon used to be nonetheless at the board.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Miss

Gorney’s lookback: Tyler Warren used to be the most efficient tight finish on this draft and this is why: Not most effective did Warren have 104 catches for 1,233 yards and 8 touchdowns this season however Penn State‘s receiving corps used to be so unhealthy that each opponent within the Big Ten knew the ball used to be going to Warren and so they could not forestall him.

He can be utilized within, out of doors, in movement, a wide variety of the way. He confirmed a few of that during highschool first as a Virginia Tech devote sooner than flipping to Penn State however OC Andy Kotelnicki and others in State College did an exquisite task being ingenious to get him the ball. In phrases of a three-star rating, despite the fact that, this used to be a overlooked alternative.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Miss

Gorney’s lookback: Jalon Walker sought after to be indexed at 6-foot-3 and 225 kilos in highschool however he measured at 6-foot-1 and 243 on the mix. From a size viewpoint, and particularly coming off the threshold, I see why we did not make Walker a five-star. But every now and then you be informed the lesson to throw out simply the ones numbers and have a look at manufacturing, velocity, go off the threshold and the power to have an never-ending motor. Walker used to be all of the ones issues at Georgia.

There are prettier edge rushers on this draft however Atlanta used to be very sensible to pick out the native Georgia Bulldogs standout as a result of no person at the defensive aspect of the ball flies round like Walker.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: The No. 2 general participant within the 2022 elegance, we obviously beloved Walter Nolen in highschool. He used to be giant and imply however proper at 300 kilos the place he may just overpower other people up the center or shoot the distance and get within the backfield.

At just below 6-foot-4 with greater than 80-inch fingers, Nolen is quicker than he even seems and will slip via offensive guards at will or push them again into the quarterback.

First at Texas A&M after which at Ole Miss, Nolen were given higher and higher in school and subsidized up his rating.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Hit

Gorney’s lookback: We did not have Shemar Stewart as a five-star till after the Under Armour Game but if we noticed him in particular person, there used to be only a projection issue there that we took under consideration – and now we are tremendous satisfied we did.

Stewart looks as if the dream defensive finish at 6-foot-5 and 267 kilos and he has an strange wingspan at just about 85 inches. The whole package deal from a bodily viewpoint is there in Stewart and if draft alternatives have been primarily based only off seems, he would struggle for No. 1 general.

It’s nonetheless befuddling that he by no means had greater than 1.5 sacks in any of his 3 seasons at Texas A&M despite the fact that.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Hit

Gorney’s lookback: Leading as much as this draft, a large number of analysts mentioned this one being about are compatible greater than the rest. Grey Zabel is a are compatible select for the Seattle Seahawks, who’ve very good younger tackles and had to shore up the interior of that offensive line.

Zabel used to be unranked popping out of highschool and had no Power Four provides. He may just’ve left and gotten some great NIL offers however he stayed at North Dakota State and ruled there. His measurements don’t seem to be off the charts however his dominance used to be at that point.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Miss

Gorney’s lookback: Maybe Roger Goodell does not understand how to pronounce his title however Emeka Ebguka has been out of the ordinary since highschool. He’s this type of cunning direction runner, so sensible and has such dependable arms.

It seemed like for a very long time that the five-star receiver from Steilacoom, Wash., may just finally end up at Oklahoma however then Ohio State were given extra concerned and he picked the Buckeyes.

Over the final 3 seasons, Egbuka – who’s so much like Jaxon Smith-Njigba – had just about 200 catches for the Buckeyes and this previous season he had extra receptions than Jeremiah Smith for the nationwide champs.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Hit

Gorney’s lookback: On the sector, Jahdae Barron makes sense, instinctive, an ideal tackler and is some other studying lesson for us as we need to undertake the concept the NFL desires cornerbacks which are at the shorter aspect and bulldogs who can assault the ball or the receiver. Barron is just below 5-11 and 194 kilos with out in particular lengthy fingers however he is a ballhawk.

His recruitment used to be a multitude, despite the fact that, as he dedicated to TCU, subsidized off that pledge and signed with Baylor however then were given his manner out of that and picked with Texas months after signing day.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Miss

Gorney’s lookback: Derrick Harmon used to be a three-star in highschool now not most effective as a result of he used to be flippantly recruited (Harmon sought after to stick domestic and play at Michigan State and that is the reason what took place) but additionally as a result of he used to be 340 kilos and had to tighten up his frame.

Through a school coaching program, Harmon weighed 313 on the mix and so long as he can stay the burden off and stay his energy then it is a little little bit of a thieve later within the first around.

Harmon used to be productive right through his time at Michigan State after which transferred to Oregon and had some other excellent season. An argument might be made that aside from Mason Graham, Harmon is the most efficient defensive take on on this elegance.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Miss

Gorney’s lookback: At greater than 5-11 and 221 kilos, the previous four-star operating again ran 4.46 on the mix and had two monster seasons at North Carolina. Over the final two seasons, Omarion Hampton had an identical stats to Ashton Jeanty on 60 fewer carries and nowhere close to the nationwide popularity or hype.

There is a draft purist in the market who cringes at two operating backs within the first around up to now however Hampton is truly price it as a wise runner, tricky and elusive sufficient with nice velocity to realize yards within the NFL.

Rated because the seventh-best operating again in his elegance, Hampton wasn’t a leave out in any way however he will have to’ve been upper nationally.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: An early TCU devote, Matthew Golden flipped to Houston and had two very forged seasons there – however almost certainly now not first-round point performances – sooner than moving to Texas the place he used to be showcased at the nationwide level and did the whole thing conceivable to polish. He had just about 1,000 receiving yards this season after which truly became it up right through the pre-draft procedure via clocking a 4.29 40-yard sprint on the mix.

He used to be ranked as a four-star however because the No. 38 vast receiver within the elegance, that used to be too low. I nonetheless assume Luther Burden is the second- or third-best receiver on this draft elegance and he has first-round skill, too.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: Donovan Jackson isn’t going to blow you away bodily however he is so strong, this type of technician and used to be nice in highschool to earn a five-star rating after which had an exquisite profession at Ohio State.

This is some other studying lesson for us, too, as Jackson is indexed at 6-foot-3.5 and 317 (even shorter than Armand Membou previous within the first around) however his wingspan is outstanding at just about 84 inches and he has nice toes.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Hit

Gorney’s lookback: I like the Jaxson Dart select as I had him because the second-best quarterback on this elegance. He performs with a large number of angle in his recreation and that is the reason what the New York Giants want for a spark of their offense.

There has been some fear in regards to the former prime four-star now not appearing up in giant video games however he is were given a ton of ability. I like his arm and his stats most effective were given higher thru his school profession, first at USC after which Ole Miss. I additionally consider Lane Kiffin‘s QB critiques and he beloved and depended on Dart to run the offense.

At Draper (Utah) Corner Canyon he performed in a wide-open offense and threw it everywhere. Things have been extra balanced at Ole Miss and now he could be a much-needed spark in NY. The enthusiasts there will have to love his fireplace.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: James Pearce has all of the characteristics of a first-round defensive finish and we appreciated him so much in highschool because the Charlotte (N.C.) Chambers defensive finish used to be a mid-level four-star however we clearly did not like him sufficient since he used to be a first-round select. Pearce is an engaging learn about as a result of he is a bit of lighter and a bit of quicker than Mykel Williams, a surefire first-round defensive finish, and he had 17.5 sacks the final two seasons in Knoxville.

There are some adulthood/personality issues throughout the pre-draft procedure with Pearce however now not sufficient to carry him again from happening Thursday evening.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: There are those that harm probably the most – guys we beloved in highschool because the best possible point of four-star possibilities however we did not pull the cause on a five-star rating after which they move within the first around. Malaki Starks suits that invoice because the Georgia protection used to be tremendous athletic and rangy with nice ball abilities in highschool. That translated completely to his time with the Bulldogs.

When we noticed Starks in highschool right through his season at Jefferson, Ga., we did really feel he used to be mailing it in a bit of bit and going throughout the motions however obviously he had the whole thing to be a first-round ability.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: Tyleik Williams in highschool used to be extra of the run stuffer, plugging form of defensive take on and whilst we appreciated him with a four-star rating, we did not see a first-round ability there. At just below 6-foot-3 and 329 kilos, that is what he’ll be within the NFL as neatly. There is not anything fallacious with that however did we see excellent athleticism or dominance alongside the defensive position in highschool? I would not say so.

Congrats to him for creating on an ideal Ohio State defensive position and coming off first amongst the ones guys as JT Tuimoloau, Jack Sawyer and others wait.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push

Gorney’s lookback: I beloved Josh Conerly in highschool and that is the reason why we made him a five-star prospect now not most effective as a result of he used to be dominant bodily however he used to be truly athletic, moved his toes so neatly and nonetheless had room to develop into his frame.

Out of Seattle (Wash.) Rainier Beach, Conerly most effective weighed 275 in highschool – one more reason that the blokes who don’t seem to be utterly stuffed out undertaking upper a large number of the days – after which got here in at 311 on the mix with lengthy fingers.

He had an ultra-crazy recruitment despite the fact that that dragged on into April sooner than he picked Oregon over USC and others.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Hit

Gorney’s lookback: Maxwell Hairston gave himself a shot to head within the first around after going 4.28 on the mix and once more, some other cornerback at 5-11.5 and 183 kilos proves that the NFL is searching for quick-twitch, rapid go-getters and now not essentially all this pretty duration at the out of doors.

We ranked him as a three-star cornerback popping out of West Bloomfield, Mich., which used to be obviously a leave out. But he used to be additionally flippantly recruited up till the tip when he picked Kentucky.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Miss

Gorney’s lookback: An early Clemson devote, Jihaad Campbell flipped to Alabama and had an exquisite profession in Tuscaloosa backing up his five-star rating. He’s the one linebacker taken in Round 1 as the location has indisputably been devalued this prime. But the Eagles could not flip down Campbell, who at just below 6-foot-3 and 235 kilos can run and canopy, blitz off the threshold and packs a punch when he will get there.

We concept Campbell would possibly develop into an edge in school however he stayed at linebacker and used to be dominant.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Hit

Gorney’s lookback: Josh Simmons is without doubt one of the extra attention-grabbing tales on this whole draft as a result of he virtually messed round an excessive amount of and came upon. Late in his highschool profession, the four-star from San Diego (Calif.) Helix were given it in his head that he sought after to pursue taking part in defensive position as an alternative of offensive line. But he struggled at a couple of occasions after which after a while determined to transport again to offensive line.

After backing off a pledge to Oregon, he selected San Diego State after which transferred to Ohio State the place he truly emerged as a first-round ability. At just about 6-foot-5 and 317 kilos, Simmons all the time had the bodily characteristics however his flip-flop between offensive and defensive position used to be a bit of worrisome.

DID WE HIT OR MISS ON HIM? … Push